A TRICK - NO treat... by PhillipLisa on 11/2/2011 via Citysearch
Ok, as is an annual tradition my wife's nephew and niece in law and great niece that used to live in New Jersey and have now relocated to Florida had flown in for an annual family/friends dinner in New Jersey. Last year we went to a great…

Stay away by jt m on 3/11/2011 via Insider Pages
Loved casey's growing up for years, unfortunately this place has gone down the tubes. Not one to review places (1st timer), always read them, but tonite's experience at Casey's warrants me to warn others. It's just not worth it to give an…

It was AWFUL. by livy m on 2/27/2011 via Insider Pages
This place honestly sucks. I went there for their teen night. And they charged me and my friend $20 to get in, We didn't have any money left over so we couldn't even check out coats. By the end of the night my phone and my friends…

Bad Place, But sorta Fun by jess s on 2/23/2011 via Insider Pages
ive been going to all the under 18 year old parties and this weekend i went and someone stole my northface and my blackberry, and my other two friends phones. i asked the bouncers for help to look since it was so dark in there and they…

Awful by Garret S on 10/29/2010 via Insider Pages
This place stinks. Literally it stinks. What a dump. Do not enter. Ten dollar cover charge for guys on thursdays!!! thats a crime. And girls are free. DISCRIMINATION!!!

Discusting place that doesnt care about its customers by Abby T on 4/15/2010 via Insider Pages
This place is terrible!!!!!!!!! Don't go here! I ordered a Coors light draft and it was flat. So i got a bud light draft and it tasted like cherries. So i told the owner they need to clean their taps and she gave me an attitude and said…

Worst place ever! by Scott K on 4/15/2010 via Insider Pages
Worst place ever!!!! We used to go here almost everyday when we worked in the area and it was managed by a competent owner. The crowd and quality then used to be great, now it's a bunch of crap! The food is horrendous, beer on tap is…

Teen Night GET IT RIGHT by Michele S on 1/12/2010 via Insider Pages
My Neice and some of her friends went there this Saturday for teen night. I would like to know why the boys have a seperate line then the girls. My neice went with 3 girls and 1 boy. The boy was the driver. He got let in and they did not.…

unhappy by jac n on 1/10/2010 via Insider Pages
This place is filthy they should shut it down. When they have teen nights people sweat all over the place. Also this place is too small to dance. The bathroom is disquisting I have no clue how they could make it clean enough to serve…

Casey O'Tooles Restaurant is a craphole by Raff P on 11/30/2009 via Insider Pages
My daughters iphone was stolen at one of their under 18 parties, they had limited security and the management could not give a crap. the police should shut that place down.

What a dive! by Beth P on 3/30/2008 via Insider Pages
This used to be Casey O'Tooles, but they changed the name, still have the same beat up ripped seats, and now bad food. I ordered the Reuben, which I thought was safe, but it was slimy! The cole slaw tasted like soap! Disappointing,…

GREAT PLACE TO HAVE LUNCH by alisa s on 3/25/2008 via Insider Pages
When meeting a friend or a business associate it is a great place to sit and talk and have a variety of food to choose from. Great location and atmosphere..

Social environment by Christina P on 3/22/2008 via Insider Pages
It has a great social environment, lots of William Paterson students attend this place. They're food has never been the greatest but the environment is the only reason to go.

Casey O'Toole's by maureen J on 3/13/2008 via Insider Pages
The wings are great. It is a good place to go for a burger and such. Theyused to offer a discount for families on Sunday's, I am not sure if they still do.

casey otooles by Kristin D on 2/3/2008 via Insider Pages
I went here for a friends birthday. The food was pretty good and the atmosphere was very cool. They have video games for younger kids as well as a bar for older people. The name has since changed and is not longer titled casey otooles.

Some data provided by Citysearch