My Review by vincentt1017906865 on 1/25/2014 via Citysearch
My family and I went to La Caselana last night for dinner. I was pleasantly surprised by the quaint and vibrant atmosphere. we were sat immediately by our server. He did a great job thru our entire meal being very attentive.\r The food…

My Review by davids1261294174 on 2/23/2013 via Citysearch
My wife and her friend both ordered the same dish in which the very next day both of them were sick! Her friend went to the doctor's and was told she has food poisoning. My wife has the same symptoms as her and for the two of them to be…

My Review by zacks29876639 on 1/26/2013 via Citysearch
I have eaten there and have also had several bad experiences, mostly with the rudeness of the nasty old blonde woman at the cash register (owner?). I finally had enough and now I go to Carmines near Eastern Hills Mall. Food is every bit as…

My Review by katev1868149317 on 1/25/2013 via Citysearch
Tonight will be the last time this restaurant will recieves my service. I have been to this locally owned restaurant a few times and every time the service has been poor. It hasn't been poor by the young waitress or waiters but by the…

Best Italian I Ever Had by Marshmello on 10/14/2011 via Citysearch
La-Castelana is located between Broadway and Como Park. If I have my choice of type of food I usually shy away from Italian EXCEPT when it comes to LaCastelana. They have the best sauce in town. \r \r You will never go wrong with the…

Best Sauce in Buffalo by mike1968 on 8/14/2010 via Citysearch
Driving down transit rd the other day looking for a quick bite to eat i stumbled on La Castelana restaurant. I had the Chicken parm with a side of spaghetti. WOW ! It was Fantastic !! With out a doubt the best Sauce in the area. I will be…

Terrible Hostess by mattmicky on 2/14/2010 via Citysearch
Waited ten minutes before hostess even acknowledged us while she spoke with her friend who already paid for a pickup order. Asked for a window seat but were given a table in the middle of a busy restaurant. The couple behind up got the…

Best Lasagne I've ever had by Dianashappy on 3/7/2009 via Citysearch
I live within walking distance of LaCastelana and get orders to go frequently. I absolutely love the lasagne. It's the best I've every had, and their sauce is also fantastic. Not too crazy about the meatballs -some days they're better…

disappointing Cabanara by Raven13 on 7/24/2008 via Citysearch
My sister took me here one friday after work and I have to say that it was disappointing. I ordered the Cabanara and the sauce consisted of shredded fried egg and egg shells rather than the velvety sauce I remembered from other times. …

Real Italian food , best sauce by mmffod on 5/30/2008 via Citysearch
This place has some of the best Italian food in the area! I have been there several times and the food is always done perfectly. It is a small place and it does get very crowded, but in the summer months they have an outside deck that is…

Horrible atmosphere!! by goobadooba on 10/1/2007 via Citysearch
Okay, the food is pretty good, if your mouth can tolerate the temperature of molton lava. They cook the food in the same plate they serve it on so it is scalding HOT. That was not my problem with this place though. The woman who operates…

Best sauce anywhere, large portions(great value) by strawbs0607 on 8/7/2006 via Citysearch
They have the best sauce I have ever had. The meatballs are almost as big as a fist and homemade and just delicious. The portions are large so it's well worth your money. The chicken and eggplant parm are lightly battered and cooked to a…

Great Italian! by JENNIFER S. on 8/8/2005 via Judy's Book
La Castelana has fabulous sauce and great food - I've never had a less than perfect meal! The Minestrone soup is the best I've ever had. They serve homemade fresh bread with every meal. The pizza is some of the best in the city! The…

Best in Buffalo !!! by mbean on 9/29/2004 via Citysearch
If your looking for great Italian food don't look any further! Try this place, I have been a customer for almost 15 years and have ALWAYS had a great dinner and service. The Italian food is the best around PERIOD !!

LOADED to go... by billc on 8/9/2002 via Citysearch
Three words: FAST, FASTER, FASTEST... That covers the LaCastelana. No, seriously, when we have out of town guest, and want we good food, in heaping platefuls, and super fast, we take them to the LaCastelana. The service has never varied.…

Some data provided by Citysearch