GARBAGE by ROB H on 4/9/2010 via Insider Pages
Simply put...this place stinks! I been told not to eat here but was overruled by friends who wanted to meet for dinner in Smithtown. Now they've learned to listen to me. If you want to eat in Smithtown....go elsewhere.

Overpriced Mess by R G on 2/20/2010 via Insider Pages
This place thinks they know how to cook seafood and pasta? Forget it. Go to LaFamilia instead.\r If you don't mind overpaying for the bottled water (H2O) and looking at year-round Christmas lights than by all means, come here.

Wednesday Night Wine Dinner by penelopepittstop on 4/17/2009 via Menuism
We went to the Wednesday night price fix dinner. It was $40 for a 3 course meal with a glass of wine paired...

Absolutely FABULOUS by Sunnyone on 1/9/2009 via Menuism
I have never left H2O Unhappy, and I don't even like seafood! The fish is always fresh, always well...

Consistently Good Food by Sharyn G on 11/26/2008 via Insider Pages
I've always had great meals here at H20. Excellent service, nice decor, everything has always been very fresh and well seasoned. Prices aren't too bad either.

Was the goods...bu no more by Jesse W on 11/22/2008 via Insider Pages
this local eatery was once the best of the best for the local area. Once Management change it went form saavy to overpriced. The occasional music in the bar was a nice addition, but certainly not a the Anniversary special meal that is once…

Great Seafood and A+ Service...Reserve Early! by Mary H. on 12/17/2006 via Judy's Book
A top class restaurant and seafood is #1. New York City restaurant quality without the long trip. Always a packed house for a reason...food is great and the atmosphere is very romantic and service is professional. Every Wednesday is a…

Not all its cracked up to be! by Shannon M on 6/8/2005 via Insider Pages
I went to this place expecting it to be of a "higher class". The restaurant was small, the decor not that great and the menu was nothing to brag about. The prices very VERY high for the food they gave you! I don't beleive it was worth it…

Some data provided by Citysearch