My Review by davida189205774 on 9/1/2017 via Citysearch
Great hole in the wall place in a cool historic building. Great home made pizza. I also enjoy the wings at this place. The people are very friendly with a neighborhood atmosphere. I highly recommend this place when you are in the Ohio…

My Review by katieb1190331201 on 12/22/2012 via Citysearch
Very disappointed in every way. Placed an order for pick up, the food was 10 minutes later then the given time. The pizza was overcooked & basically burnt. I also ordered garlic bread with cheese. Not only was I not given the extra sauce I…

this place is go to for great pizza! by Anniemcmz on 12/18/2011 via Citysearch
Ohio city pizzeria is a refreshing change of tempo from all of those ridiculous chains. Whenever my family visits they demand pizza from here. Service is on time and prices are reasonable. Unlike Edisons, which also has great pizza, the…

my favorite pizza by felecia anderson on 9/19/2010 via Citysearch
Best pizza in town.2 large tow toppings for 20 bucks! Oh yeah!!!!

By far the best - what are those other ones talking about? by jandbgeb on 6/29/2010 via Citysearch
We order for OC Pizza all the time - it is incredibly good pizza and they always know who we are. It comes very quickly and it always tastes fresh. I can't recommend this place enough!

Awesome Pizza, People & Service by maia2976 on 4/2/2009 via Citysearch
Pretty awesome tasting pizza unless you like the "chain pizza" available everywhere else...\r I've always had timely pickup or delivery.\r The staff are wonderfully welcoming and will remember you!

Good luck... by ritchiedogs on 10/24/2008 via Citysearch
All I have to say is good luck ordering, receiving, and enjoying your pizza. I've ordered from here one other time, and attempted to again today. Never again! The first time I ordered, the pizza not only took forever to get to my house…

Don't believe those reviews by westSieeeeeed on 8/7/2008 via Citysearch
Ohio city pizza is the bomb. Best pizza in town. I think the people who wrote those bad comments are from the suburbs and are all used to Donatos or something. (OR they own like a dominos! or a Donatos! corportate sabotage!!!) You…

DONT WASTE YOUR TIME OR MONEY WITH OHIO CITY PIZZERIA by gregtooth on 1/1/2008 via Citysearch
I CANT BELIEVE A BUSINESS WOULD OPERATE IN THE FASHION THAT OHIO CITY PIZZA DOES!\r THE WOMAN WHO HANDLES THE PHONE IS UNBELIEVABLY RUDE AND THE WAIT TIME IS OUTRAGEOUS. YOU ARE BETTER OFF GETTING NUNZIOS!

No more second chances... by 701wlakeside on 1/30/2006 via Citysearch
The first time we tried Ohio Citys pizza it was average at best. But, given the lack of options we decided to give them a second chance. On our second attempt we waited well over an hour to receive a call that the pizza was being sent…

Best Pizza in Ohio City by pocphil on 12/31/2005 via Citysearch
We've tried several of their pizzas. Their Sausage is fresh from the market and the hawaiian pizza is delicious. We've had excellent service and we order from them at least every 2 weeks. This is NOT cheapo-junk pizza. Top Quality and Top…

I WISH they had good pizza!! by foodie32 on 1/15/2003 via Citysearch
I cannot believe the reviews I've seen here for Ohio City Pizza - I have tried it several times- always disappointed- the pizzas were dry and lacked flavor. Still searching for a good pizza in the area!

Disappointing Service by CNJones on 10/21/2002 via Citysearch
I LOVE Ohio City Pizza....the pizza is fabulous. The service on the other hand is atrocious. I used to order pizza from OCP every time I had a craving. I refuse to be a patron of OCP anymore because last time I ordered I waited 2 HOURS…

Some data provided by Citysearch