My Review by 'bren on 10/23/2012 via Citysearch
I have been eating here since the early 2000's...I love the food, the staff is always friendly, funny & experienced. I love their menu & I am visiting in the Gibsonia area and will eat there this Thursday!!!

Great food, horrible service - not worth it at the moment. by Kate K. on 4/20/2010 via Judy's Book
I went to Cala Lilly first with my parents, a friend my age (20s) and her mother. We were seated very quickly, and the ambience is nice, it's a very romantic setting. However, our server took forever (at least 10 minutes) to come over to…

Cala Lilly Cafe is mostly good. by Georgia K on 8/27/2009 via Insider Pages
This is a very small but nice restaurant. I have had some good meals and some not very good meals there. My crab cakes were full of shells. The warm pita bread rolls are delicious.

Hidden gem. by Tony K on 8/23/2009 via Insider Pages
Unimposing exterior (in a strip mall) but don't let that dissuade you. When this restaurant opened, it had the best service and really wonderful food. Both have declined somewhat. However, they can surprise with a wonderful quinoa side…

I feel robbed by ClassyYinzer on 5/23/2009 via Citysearch
Saw this restaurant on the top 10 list so I just had to drive 45 minutes out to it. Especially since it was paired with eleven and other similar caliber restaurants. What a joke. Cala Lily's you should be ashamed to rob people like that.…

AMAZING MEAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!! by lucy31 on 2/16/2009 via Citysearch
We went to the Cala Lilly Cafe over the weekend and it was AMAZING! You'd never know it from the outside, but the service, staff and food was spectacular! We had drinks at the bar--a cala Lilly flirtini for me (great!)...Sat down to…

Awesome Experience by LOVETOEATPITT on 6/14/2008 via Menuism
Holy Canoli this place was great! Since having lived in the metro New York and Chicago areas, I was nervous...

Make reservations! by sheri s on 1/31/2008 via Insider Pages
This little place is tricky to find, but worth looking! Fantastic expansive menu. Small, cozy, but not crowded. Romantic setting! Service was good. Food was served hot and the portion size was adequate. \r \r Since we didn't have a…

Some data provided by Citysearch