New Yorker Pizza & Restaurant

Reviews for New Yorker Pizza & Restaurant

New Yorker Pizza & Restaurant received an average rating of 3.67 out of 5 stars from 12 reviews.

Write a review

by Quinton on 2/16/2021

 

by Eshe on 4/15/2021

 

by Guadalupe on 6/13/2021

 

by Tamara on 8/11/2021

 

by Ibragim on 1/30/2021

 

by steve on 5/18/2021

 

by gomez on 3/4/2021

 

by Amita on 6/29/2021

 

by Shimon on 10/14/2021

 

by Mathilda on 4/5/2021

 

by Farquhar on 7/31/2021

 

by Amon on 9/28/2021

 

My Review by heidis1719698533 via Citysearch on 6/30/2015

They're not closed!!!

Little New Yorker Pizza by ivy_L via Menuism on 6/29/2013

This pizza is so good we always get some for special nights and just for fun. Their house pizza is the best...

My Review by tracys1627395841 via Citysearch on 7/29/2012

Worth a trip up from Novato for sure. My hubby and I love coming here and going to the movies down the street. Their pizza is so good!! It has spoiled us for anything in Novato, hence the drive. They also have great salads, nice…

Best pick when in Petaluma. by pam Z via Insider Pages on 11/25/2010

My Favorite Pizza in Petaluma!\r \r So yummy and the staff is always kind. Sure, they only take cash/check, but they got an ATM in there at least. \r The only downside is the food's so good that my belly is starting to show it =)

Horrible serivce Horrible Waitress by CASSAM123 via Menuism on 8/27/2010

This was the worst service my family and I have had at a restaurant. We ate here after a day of shopping...

Horrible Service Horrible Waitress by cassam123 via Citysearch on 8/26/2010

My family and I went to this retaurant with our children after a day of shopping. This was the worst experience I have ever had. The waitress did not provide any customer service to us while we were there and never came back to see if we…

New Yorker Pizza & Restaurant is friendly by D S via Insider Pages on 8/7/2009

Italian food at moderate prices with friendly staff. They have a way of making you feel like you are eating in a friends kitchen! You won't be disappointed!

A taste of little Italy by jss309 via Menuism on 12/17/2008

The interpretations here have the classic endemic overtones of authentic Italian food from New York city...

Pizza Perfect! by QCB via Citysearch on 3/14/2008

There is no doubt in my mind that this is one of our town?s best restaurants. I have been a patron for over 15 years, and the quality never falters. The service is always excellent, the food is wonderful, and the prices are great! If you…

RUDE RUDE RUDE! by tomj78 via Citysearch on 9/4/2007

This is, hands down, the worst restaurant I've EVER been to. I'm new to the area (military) and decided to explore some pizza joints. This was the third place I went to. As I walked in, the door was propped open to allow the fresh air…

Best Petaluma Italian for the local neighborhood by wickedroon via Citysearch on 7/31/2007

Mama Mia, this is my favorite Italian Restaurant. (Closed on Monday) Tasty homemade food!! \r My wife and I began eating here over a year ago. I've dabbled in other italian eateries to be honest but I keep coming back to New Yorker. …

Rude service,cold , rubbery pizza with raw dough by nelliestar via Citysearch on 2/25/2007

We were very dissappointed, after waiting 30 minutes when no customers were there!\r The pizza had virtually no meat on it or cheese.....and was on a rubbery, doughy crust.\r It was dry .\r We very politely complained, and were told we…

Best pizza in town by giantsphan via Citysearch on 7/12/2005

Fantastic family-owned restaurant in downtown Petaluma, near the new movie theater. Casual, classic dishes, and great authentic New York style pizza.

The BEST Garlic Bread in the World!!! by 685cada via Citysearch on 6/28/2004

Hi, I found this place maybe 10 years ago and it has GREAT FOOD! We enjoyed the pizza and pasta alot, but my real favorite is the GARLIC BREAD!!! Order some when you first get there and you'll probably love it so much that you'll get an…