My Review by eltyshaun via Citysearch on 6/26/2012

Im a former New yorker, love the pizza, taste like home, took my woman here and she's from north carolina and she loves the pizza as well......no complaints so far, sorry that mostly everyone on here had a bad experience............

Barley qualifies as pizza by pizzaguy2011 via Citysearch on 8/28/2011

If you are broke college kid or you happen to work at NCSU than you can make the excuse to eat here(ever once in a while). However, if you don't fall into of those categories then you are fool to spend your money here.\r \r I bought 2…

ROACHES by BCMacKintosh via Citysearch on 1/8/2011

While I was eating my pizza, a roach crawled right over my foot and ran behind a door. Not coming back here!

Silvia's by Cyberdactyl via Citysearch on 10/21/2010

Parked behind Silvi'as to grab a slice. It was late morning and found they had not opened yet. I strolled over to Brugger's for a bagel instead. Went out to my truck and it was gone. I was towed because the "spotters" saw me go over…

I love New York Pizza by Sonya N via Insider Pages on 2/5/2010

This is the best pizza I've tasted from a small restaurant. I'll take it over Pizza Hut and Papa John's any day. The wings are great too!

Stay away from this place by mwhawk via Citysearch on 9/18/2009

I went inside for a pizza. I stayed about 45 minutes. I went to the parking lot and my car was gone. This pizza store called Atlantic towing and had my car towed while I was inside eating pizza Atalantic Towing towed my car to the…

I Love Ny Pizza is alrite by cris j via Insider Pages on 7/10/2009

I guess this is one of the busiest places on hills borough . I would say the pizzas are great and are definitely affordable . But service is definitely a problem here and also the atmosphere sometimes gets hot and stuffy .

I Love Ny Pizza is Not a great place for Pizza by ram s via Insider Pages on 7/10/2009

Pizza's here are really horrible. This is with respect to the vegetarian pizza's. I had been to this place twice, both the times the quality of pizza are really very bad. I have no idea about other pizza types. If you are a vegetarian,…

It tastes like a slice of home! by Renter78150502 via Citysearch on 5/7/2009

It is awesome to find a good Pizza place in Raleigh. Former NY'r here who loves this place. \r Mellow is ok but over priced, while I love, gives you good pizza, priced well!\r They should check their attitudes though, sometimes I think…

Don't bother by 21ja via Citysearch on 1/28/2008

Really, it wasn't worth going over there. It looks like the real deal but isn't. Not sure if it was just an off night considering the reviews it has received. If you are looking for NY pizza Assiagio's is much better. Take it from a…

Food is OK but nothing special by mattshamblin via Citysearch on 12/17/2007

Food here is alright I guess, it's just what you're used to everywhere else. Can't really knock them for anything but it's the same thing you get at all the other "NY style" knock off places around the country.

Best Pizza in Raleigh, Possibly NC! by ricardocobos via Citysearch on 10/30/2007

First of all, the name says it all NEW YORK pizza. That means it will be thin crust (dough made fresh daily hand flown) and little to no tomato sauce. I would rather not eat pizza than eat bad pizza, this is GREAT pizza!

Best NY Pizza in NC by pro115 via Citysearch on 6/12/2007

If you want authentic NY style pizza this is the place to go! I have been to this location and the Wilmington, NC location both are great!

The real deal by cchik via Citysearch on 8/25/2006

I LOVE THIS PIZZA!!! My niece attends Peace College and she kept raving about it. I finally drove the 30 minutes to get there and it was absolutely fantastic. Authentic NY pizza! I took my husband there two days later. We are hooked. …

Best Pizza in Raleigh by machinus via Citysearch on 8/24/2006

I have been to hundreds of pizzerias in NY, CA, MA, and NC. This is among the best pizza I have eaten in all of north carolina. It is truly authentic new york style pizza and it is delicious. Highly recommended!

I'm a fan by emily p. via Judy's Book on 4/12/2006

I'm a huge fan of I Love New York pizza, specifically for its pizza by the slice. I Love New York has several pizzas cooked and ready to go all the time, you can then go in an request a slice of your choice and have it popped in the oven…

Grab a slice #5 by Craig K. via Judy's Book on 4/10/2006

Other places with good pizza in the Triangle include:Pepper's (written elsewhere)I Love NY PizzaMellow Mushroom (for a chain)The place next to B&J's by whole foods.Unlike most place in the country. you can find a great slice in the heart…

Cheap and yummy pizza by Kristy L. via Judy's Book on 12/11/2005

As a fan of thin crust pizza, this place is one of my favorites on Hillsborough Street. Even though prices have gone up in recent years, 2 huge slices of chese pizza and a drink for $4 is a great deal, and you won't leave hungry. The…

not very good by Jean W via Insider Pages on 11/5/2005

generally the prices here are higher than its counterparts elsewhere, but the taste of pizzas are ok. still, one or two tries you'd feel it ok, but more, you wouldn't.

ABSOLUTE WORST PIZZA IN RALEIGH!!! by mamieclyde1 via Citysearch on 10/29/2005

Horrible pizza. I ordered an XL to go, got it home, it had no pizza sauce on it, so I fed the "cheese bread" to my dogs, and gave the rest to my friend to feed to her dogs. I called the store immediately, was told the manager wasn't there,…

Write a review

Map & Directions

Claim this business

Report Closed Some data provided by Citysearch

I Love New York Pizza

Reviews for I Love New York Pizza

Browse By Category

I Love New York Pizza (919) 838-0011