Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza serves Staten Island, NY and is located in the 10314 ZIP code.
Reviews for Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza
Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza received an average rating of 3.73 out of 5 stars from 15 reviews.
Write a review
by James on 8/6/2021
by Mike on 10/4/2021
by Lando on 4/4/2021
by Jomez on 7/20/2021
by Jomez on 7/20/2021
by steve on 9/17/2021
by steve on 9/17/2021
by steve on 9/17/2021
by Samael on 3/9/2021
by Samael on 3/9/2021
by Artturi on 6/24/2021
by Artturi on 6/24/2021
by Breda on 5/6/2021
by Breda on 5/6/2021
by gomez on 7/4/2021
My Review by Jessica via GrubHub on 5/22/2014
Excellent fast service and delicious food
Goodfella's Victory in Staten island !!!Is... by elmira via Menuism on 11/2/2013
Goodfella's Victory in Staten island !!!Is discus ting !!!! horrible !!! Customer service 0 % !!!! i will...
Best Pizza! by Gabe B via Insider Pages on 8/24/2011
High class pizza. Oh my... The Pizza ala Vodka is superb. Worth the trip from wherever you are for their pizza. I came from NJ, and will not flinch or hesitate to do it again. LOVE THIS PLACE!
John C by John c via Insider Pages on 1/16/2011
I Go to the origanal goodfellas at 1718 Hylan blvd its the best place on staten island for a great pizza and service! goodfellas.com will take you to the origanal goodfellas
mr p by soct c via Insider Pages on 1/8/2011
The best pizza ever vodka pie wood fired brick oven say no more if you love pizza you have to go the Original Goodfellas 1718 hylan blvd\r
and try the calamari no joke best in town!
no by John K via Insider Pages on 9/20/2010
dont order from here... ive ordered and somehow there food always comes in cold even and when you call back they fix your order are rude and never actually fix it....aweful customer service... the food is good ... but really .... cold?...…
Goodfella's Victory is the best by joe h via Insider Pages on 10/20/2009
the best pizza in Staten Island. incredible service in a warm cozy atmospehere. they make you feel like family. wood fired pizza and fresh mozzarella with the best and freshest ingredients. family owned!
INCREDIBLE by joe p via Citysearch on 10/19/2009
This place is gold. The pizza is cooked in a big wood fired brick oven and they specialize in fresh mozzarella and gourmet pizzas. The pastas and entrees are healthy size portions and I always wind up taking some home. The service in…
incredible by Andrew S. via Judy's Book on 10/19/2009
best pizza and service on the island. warm cozy friendly place always
Absolutely the best!! by Robert S via Insider Pages on 11/11/2007
Goodfellas pizza is the best pizza i have ever had! I've eaten in many different pizzarias and it is hands down, the best. The dough has a flavor of it's own, the sauce is sweet with a little spice and the cheese, oh the cheese! All…
Closest to real Italian in NYC by Ice B via Insider Pages on 11/9/2006
I lived in Naples, Italy...the best pizza in the world!! Goodfellas' specialty pies are great. Pizza a la Vodka is scrumptious and the NY style regular pizza is fabulous sometimes a little too salty but one of the best I've had in the…
Goodfella's by Lisa H. via Judy's Book on 8/24/2005
This Italian restaurant is pretty laid back with great service. The food is absolutely superb especially the pizza's. A must try is the A La Vodka Pizza which is mouth-watering good. The location isn't the best but for the great food,…
Dismal service by bayridgeryan via Citysearch on 8/2/2005
While there's a decent menu, it shouldn't take ten minutes to get your drinks and 45 for a dessert pizza. We ended up having to just leave because we were essentially being ignored by the wait staff--even though the rest of the restaurant…
Still bad by bridge_girl via Citysearch on 11/9/2004
Since the opening under new management I was excited to start eating there again. Before the service was so lousy the orders were constantly mixed up. But I was dissappointed yet again. I ordered something and they brought the wrong item…
Decent food... if you can wait for it! by macguyeric via Citysearch on 10/12/2003
Spotty service - took 20 minutes to get the order taken, even though we were the only people in the place who didn't have food and there were only a few other groups there. Then, after waiting more than 45 minutes for a desert pizza, we…
