1st Choice Insurance Services

Welcome to 1st Choice Insurance Services located in North Judson, Indiana.

1st Choice Insurance Services is an insurance carrier in Indiana. We are independent agents representing a variety of companies. 1st Choice always works to get its clients the insurance deals that make perfect sense for their needs and budgets. You can count on 1st Choice to work for you.

We offer insurance for a wide array of domains, including:

- Auto
- Health
- Home
- Life
- Farm
- Crops
- Group and Business

We have served the region since 1896, in one form or another. Our President, Paul D. Croyle, has been an insurance agent for the last 45 years. We also have a variety of other insurance agents ready to help you.

Our policies combine solid coverage with flexible premiums that make sense for you. Choosing the right insurance doesn't have to be a difficult and confusing mystery. We lay out every important aspect of your insurance, and help you select the policy best suited to meet your needs.

For more information about working with us, give us a call today.

We serve all your insurance needs from auto, health, home, life, farm, crop, group and business - we offer convenient monthly payment plans.