1. Pizza Cottage - Buckeye Lake

(740) 928-1144

4592 Walnut Rd Buckeye Lake, OH 43008

2. Little Caesars Pizza

(740) 345-1755

250 Granville Street Newark, OH 43055

3. Donatos Pizza

(740) 366-0777

1059 North 21st Street Newark, OH 43055

Try our new Bakery Crust Pizza!

4. Domino's Pizza

(740) 366-7347

1226 N 21st St Newark, OH 43055

Click Here & Buy 2-Med 2-Topping Pizzas 6.99 Each

5. Domino's Pizza

(740) 527-3700

1000 Hebron Rd Heath, OH 43056

Click Here & Buy 2-Med 2-Topping Pizzas 6.99 Each

6. Park Pizza

(740) 344-6555

354 Union St. Newark, OH 43055

7. Dirko's Pizza

(740) 345-6814

1000 E Main St Newark, OH 43055

8. Debra's Pizza

(740) 345-1350

318 Hudson Ave Newark, OH 43055

9. Christy's Pizza

(740) 522-5193

13 E Church St Newark, OH 43055

10. Pizza Hut

(740) 344-3434

744 W Main St Newark, OH 43055

Pizza Hut is Open for Carryout & Delivery

11. Marco's Pizza

(740) 348-0019

221 N 21st St Newark, OH 43055

12. Plaza Pizza

(740) 366-5627

1130 Mount Vernon Rd Newark, OH 43055

13. Crenos Pizza

(740) 587-1202

1256 Columbus Rd Granville, OH 43023

14. Domino's Pizza

(740) 928-3030

118 E Main St Hebron, OH 43025

15. Hanover Pizza

(740) 763-4561

2255 W High St Newark, OH 43055

16. Domino's Pizza

(740) 527-3030

457 E Main St Hebron, OH 43025

17. Rosa's Pizza

(740) 973-1426

771 S 30th St Heath, OH 43056

18. Carmen's Pizza

(740) 349-9291

106 W National Dr Newark, OH 43055

19. Donatos Pizza

(740) 522-7980

527 Hebron Rd Heath, OH 43056

Try our new Bakery Crust Pizza!

20. Montell's Pizza

(740) 659-2177

103 S Main St Glenford, OH 43739

21. Domino's Pizza

(740) 349-3016

77 W Main St Newark, OH 43055

22. Pounder's Pizza

(740) 522-4563

2066 Cherry Valley Rd Newark, OH 43055

23. Crenos Pizza

(740) 522-0766

381 S 30th St Heath, OH 43056

24. Louie's Pizza

(740) 344-7931

1019 Westgate Ave Newark, OH 43055

25. Crenos Pizza

(740) 522-0030

381 S 30th St Heath, OH 43056

26. Creno's Pizza

(740) 928-2300

11184 Hebron Rd Buckeye Lake, OH 43008

27. Donatos Pizza

(740) 920-4774

116 E Broadway Granville, OH 43023

28. Firehouse Pizza

(740) 246-5969

4 N Main St Thornville, OH 43076

29. Donatos Pizza

(740) 928-7174

11048 Hebron Rd Buckeye Lake, OH 43008

Try our new Bakery Crust Pizza!

30. Stonebro's Pizza

(740) 892-3100

237 Central Ave Newark, OH 43055

31. Plaza Pizza

(740) 899-5900

830 S 30th St Heath, OH 43056

32. Roxy's Pizza & Restaurant

(740) 467-2989

12110 Lancaster St Millersport, OH 43046

33. Doug's Point Pizza

(740) 345-2901

290 N Cedar St Newark, OH 43055

34. Central City Pizza

(740) 788-8522

1868 Cherry Valley Rd Newark, OH 43055

35. Panther Pizza & Ice Cream

(740) 763-3111

2448 W High St NE Hanover, OH 43055

36. Pizza Cottage - Newark

(740) 366-5747

969 Mt Vernon Rd Newark, OH 43055

37. Don & Sue's Pizza

(740) 522-8457

730 W Church St Newark, OH 43055

38. New Village Pizza

(740) 467-2282

12404 Lancaster St Millersport, OH 43046

39. Pizza Hut Express

(740) 925-5588

10258 Lancaster Road SW Hebron, OH 43025

40. Backroads Pizza LLC

(740) 928-0580

118 E Main St Newark, OH 43055

41. Pizza Hut - Closed

(740) 366-7314

1825 N 21st St Newark, OH 43055

42. Too Tall's Pizza

(740) 349-7441

529 E Main St Newark, OH 43055

43. Incredible Pizza Co

(740) 345-4455

391 W Main St Newark, OH 43055

44. Dan's Family Pizza

(740) 349-7743

400 W Main St Newark, OH 43055

45. The Elm's Pizza Parlor

(740) 587-1032

113 E Elm St Granville, OH 43023

46. Papa Johns Pizza

(740) 522-1661

566 HEBRON RD Heath, OH 43056

Click here for Papa Johns deals and specials

47. Pizza Hut - Closed

(740) 522-8164

846 Hebron Rd Heath, OH 43056

48. Little Pizza House

(740) 246-5809

13034 King Rd NE Thornville, OH 43076

49. Brewsky's Pizza & Drive Thru

(740) 670-8430

81 Calburn St. Newark, OH 43055

50. Dan's Family Pizza

(740) 349-8549

400 W Main St Newark, OH 43055