Payment accepted Discover
Payment accepted Mastercard
Price 2 - Moderately Priced
Prices Main courses $4.95-$15 lunch, $11-$22 dinner
Reservations Reservations not accepted, except for large parties
Reviews for Jessop's Tavern
Jessop's Tavern received an average rating of 2.89 out of 5 stars from 18 reviews.
Write a review
by Amita on 4/18/2021
by Shimon on 8/3/2021
by Shimon on 8/3/2021
by Shimon on 8/3/2021
by Mathilda on 1/23/2021
by Mathilda on 1/23/2021
by Mathilda on 1/23/2021
by Mathilda on 1/23/2021
by brockton on 10/1/2021
by brockton on 10/1/2021
by Amanda on 3/23/2021
by Amanda on 3/23/2021
by Amanda on 3/23/2021
by Amanda on 3/23/2021
by EnD on 2/1/2021
by EnD on 2/1/2021
by Farquhar on 5/20/2021
by Farquhar on 5/20/2021
The WORST by ACustomer19 via Menuism on 1/12/2014
I had such an awful experience at Jessop's Tavern. I wish I could leave Zero stars. A group of friends and...
My Review by joec949952860 via Citysearch on 8/30/2013
When starting the planning process of our wedding, my fiance & I went to many places in Old New Castle but I had always loved Jessop's Tavern since the first time we went several years ago. I had decided to have the reception there, but I…
AMAZING by jtc818 via Menuism on 8/30/2013
When starting the planning process of our wedding, my fiance & I went to many places in Old New Castle but...
Mr. by Al S via Insider Pages on 2/15/2011
Let's see.....It's Valentine's Day and one would think a restaurant known for good beer selection would have decent beer on tap. Boy was I wrong! Not only did they NOT have any good beer, it was freezing cold in the dining and bar area. If…
DON'T GO if you are not a Local by Steve M. via Judy's Book on 2/21/2010
Valentines Day,I wanted to take my wife some place special. We ended up at Jessop's Tavern seemed like a very romantic idea. We arrived and the restuarunt was wounderful, the waitress very nice. The manager/ bar keep made our visit so…
Jessop's Tavern is Not All That by CC A via Insider Pages on 7/14/2009
The atmosphere was quaintly rustic. The staff was AWESOME!! The food was disappointing,especially for the price. Nothing special that I could not make better myself. Fish cakes were so DRY I could not enjoy them. Cherry cobbler was tasty,…
Great Ambience by Nicole S via Insider Pages on 6/10/2009
The wait staff was awesome. I had a fantastic reuben sandwich and french onion soup. A wonderful colonial atmosphere in historic New Castle. Definitely a must see
cold food, really bad service by J P via Insider Pages on 3/1/2009
We were there in April of 2008. Let me preface this by saying we really like historical restaurants, so we weren't put off by the old building or the menu. Our food was cold. Our waitress was awful. The rest of the wait staff ignored us,…
Unique Dining Experience by Allyson M via Insider Pages on 5/22/2006
I really enjoy this restaurant. The wait used to be unbearable. Either business has slowed or they get people in and out quicker. But it is still a nice dining experience. I love the costumes and the old-fashioned fare. However - do…
Not so popular any more, but still as good as when they started by Beth N via Insider Pages on 12/22/2005
When this place first opened, you could never be seated at a table without waiting hours, and they wouldn't take reservations. Not sure if it was the uniqueness that attracted everyone, or the food. Noshing has changed, but they are no…
