Reviews for Costellos Pizzeria
Costellos Pizzeria received an average rating of 4.00 out of 5 stars from 1 reviews.
Write a review
by Umberto on 10/17/2021
My Review by Food Critis via Urbanspoon on 2/18/2012
First thing that should have clued us in was EVERYONE was eating pizza! Sadly we ordered Chicken Parmigiana & Alla Bolognese w/ Sausage. The chicken was overcooked and tough, the Bolognese is basically crumbled meat on the pasta (I had to…
My Review by Jeff via Urbanspoon on 8/10/2011
Great pizza and nice place to grab a drink. Fantastic stromboli and service as well.
Mediocre Italian at a Good Price by Hellyna H via Insider Pages on 4/14/2011
I've been here a few times and I've had differing experiences each time. I usually order something simple like spaghetti and meatballs. Let me start off by saying the garlic rolls are fantastic - they are soft, warm, and have the perfect…
My Review by Pnemiller via Urbanspoon on 4/12/2011
We had not been to this local place in Jupiter in a few years. Had some good basic spaghetti and meatballs--very good marina sauce. Plattters come with soup or salad and terrific garlic bread. Tomato bisque soup was very tasty. Drinks were…
My Review by S Sellars via Urbanspoon on 4/7/2011
We ordered pizza from this place Monday night... out of the 4 pizza's one was not burned.... they credited us which was great @ 6.99 a pie. Called in an order tonight to use the credit.. ordered 2 pies and pasta dish along with a salad and…
My Review by H. Lyne via Urbanspoon on 2/22/2011
We decided to try Costello's over the weekend. We were seated and waited about 10 minutes before another couple sat down next to us. Although servers walked in and out, no one acknowledged us. When the couple that arrived 20 minutes after…
My Review by Chris L via Urbanspoon on 12/1/2010
Recently my wife & I had the pleasure of dining at Costello's. The place was quaint and the management & staff were amazing. Everyone makes you feel like part of the family. The menu has something to please anyone and was priced…
My Review by Chris L via Urbanspoon on 12/1/2010
Excellent Pizza, one of the best I have had. Living in So. Jersey we have plenty of pizza places owned by people directly from Italy and Costello's is right up there with them. Loved the pepperoni & sausage pizza, the sauce is great and…
My Review by Nina via Urbanspoon on 12/1/2010
While on vacation we had the great pleasure of dining at Costello's. The staff was very attentive and the food was excellent. Our group of 5 all had different dishes and no one had anything but rave reviews about their meal. From pizza to…
My Review by Nina via Urbanspoon on 12/1/2010
Excellent combination of tang & spice from the garlic and sage combined with the sweetness of pears & cheese wrapped in a thin pasta. Perfect with a glass of wine from the wine list.
My Review by Nina via Urbanspoon on 12/1/2010
Hand tossed by Jason and cooked perfectly. A crisp bottom with crust done just right. Menu has a wide selection of toppings and specialty pizza's
My Review by Nina via Urbanspoon on 12/1/2010
The bar staff is prepared to make you any flavor Mojito you could want. They specialize in different flavors but can make a standard Mojito as well. Great bar for just sitting and relaxing with friends.
My Review by AJ via Urbanspoon on 11/5/2010
Poor slow service. Very rude wait staff who forget who is paying the tab. I won't be back.
My Review by Tom via Urbanspoon on 6/12/2010
First time using urbanspoon we. chose this restraint for the review posted and we are glade we did everything was great
My Review by Regina via Urbanspoon on 7/19/2009
Good food; wait usually not too long, but service not always fast
My Review by Lisa Barker via Urbanspoon on 6/16/2009
We ate at Costellos twice during our stay at Jupiter. The bread was amazing. Everything was fresh and savory. The tiramiso and cheesecake was made from scratch. awesome delicious !!!
