Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

Write a review

My Review by nellygar01 via Urbanspoon on 9/17/2012

First of all, the girls at the front door have attitudes and are horrible at their job very immature and not interested in customer service friendliness or overall care for working. I looked in on the guys cooking the pizza. I saw them…

My Review by 561 via Urbanspoon on 7/30/2011

pizza is awesome, so are the wings.

My Review by greekchic12 via Urbanspoon on 7/16/2011

This is the best pizza I've ever had... My family and friends are hooked since the first visit.. Love the atmosphere..\r Favorite is the Fresh Mozz with sauce and basil pizza.. WIngs to die for.. Broccoli Rabbe and Sausage side and the…

My Review by FloridaGirl84 via Urbanspoon on 6/26/2011

Pizza is just ok. Nothing special. I tried a calzone today with pepperoni. It want cooked all the way. Very few pepperonis in the whole calzone. It didn't have much flavor and I'd have to say it was the worst one I've ever tried. I will…

My Review by Stacey S. via Urbanspoon on 6/22/2011

I've eaten here before (about a year ago) and it was pretty good. Today, I decided to have lunch and order a small pep and mushroom to go. Wouldn't you know, the bottom and the edges were horribly burned. It tasted...well, it didn't have a…

My Review by Food Critic via Urbanspoon on 5/15/2011

I must say everything is most excellent. We have been back many times and never disappointed.

My Review by ihatecrap via Urbanspoon on 5/2/2011

Noisy and austere environment. Service weak. Food weak. I watched several guys from, looks like 'Guatemala, Italy' burn a pizza. Several times the pizza was not enjoyable. Value for the money, 2 out of 10! $5 bottled beer? Not once, have I…

My Review by Chris via Urbanspoon on 3/20/2011

Terrible pizza. Pizza should NOT be cooked with coal. I don't understand how anyone would want gritty coal dust and soot on their food.

My Review by Cindy via Urbanspoon on 3/1/2011

If you have never tried pizza cooked over a wood fire, it is definitely worth a try. I decided to write a review of Anthony's to give a different perspective from most pizza reviews. If I were going to order a generic pepperoni pizza, I…

My Review by Joan Sorensen via Urbanspoon on 2/12/2011

Great place for coal fired pizza. We just happened to be at Anthony's on the opening day and have been coming back ever since. Menu is limited but we only come for the large, tomato and sweet pepper pizza. This is our favorite. Service is…

My Review by SurferEats via Urbanspoon on 2/2/2011

First visit was just fine. Good balanced pizza. Pretty good service. Not expecting much for the price. Second visit convinced me not to bother returning. Our waiter must have just got out of training. He brought the wrong pizza as it was…

My Review by FoodieGuide via Urbanspoon on 12/18/2010

Ever since my first visit to Anthony's I have become a gigantic fan of this restaurant. Normally I wouldn't wait 20-30 minutes to eat at a pizza place but for some reason ever since my first visit I have been hooked. \r \r Once you get…

My Review by anova1931 via Urbanspoon on 9/6/2010

Great pizza, even better wings!!!

My Review by Mk dy via Urbanspoon on 7/1/2010

Pizza was wet and floppy,server very nice.

My Review by Talula via Urbanspoon on 6/17/2010

To begin with, Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza only has bottled beer. :(\r \r The pizza is lackluster with much to much sauce. We had the Eggplant Marino, and the leftovers drenched the takeout box. The menu claims that pizza features basil but…

My Review by David A. via Urbanspoon on 4/5/2010

I thought the pizza was great! Very crowded but they do a good job of moving people through and the wait wasn't unreasonable. Because of the openness of the room and the seating, it's rather loud - but I'm fine with that in a good pizza…

My Review by KLFinNPB via Urbanspoon on 12/14/2009

Good and bad. We have had some wonderful pizza, but when we had take out the pizza was burnt. Everything we had at the restaurant was great.

My Review by Michelle via Urbanspoon on 11/18/2009

We always have the house salad, chicken wings, meatball pizza, and gorgonzola pizza. Definitely a great family restaurant

My Review by ctotl919 via Urbanspoon on 11/3/2009

We were looking forward to trying this coal fired pizza and the restaurant. What a disappointment! Way overpriced for what you get, food and pizza merely OK. Noisy, uncomfortable chairs, untrained service, huge tvs all over the place. Not…

My Review by Niko via Urbanspoon on 7/30/2009

Excellent Pizza! Better ghan NyC! Try the eggplant Marino, roasted chicken wings, broccoli rabbe eigh sausage- yum!!! The best!!!