Paulie's Pizzeria

Reviews for Paulie's Pizzeria

Paulie's Pizzeria received an average rating of 4.25 out of 5 stars from 4 reviews.

Write a review

by Abram on 5/11/2021

 

by brockton on 10/31/2020

 

by brockton on 10/31/2020

 

by Amanda on 2/16/2021

 

Not so hot by T K via Insider Pages on 11/24/2010

Sorry guys, but Paulie's is just edible. Been going there for years too (I grew up in Tenafly!) and have lived here and NYC all of my life. This is not great pizza. Yes, the owner is a nice guy but that speaks nothing of the food. I prefer…

Very yummy! by Irene T via Insider Pages on 10/31/2008

I absolutely love Paulie's Pizza! I used to go all the time to this pizza-place when I used to live in the area. I remember the owner being really nice, the pizza being delicious, and the prices very reasonable! What makes this place…

Worth it by Rejo C via Insider Pages on 3/12/2008

Living in this area for the past 20 years and having parents that give me money to dine out, I took the opportunity to see as many places as possible. I came across Paulies and I can definitely say that I had a great time there. It had…

Paulies by Jin J. via Judy's Book on 10/7/2005

The best pizzaria in Tenaflt in my opinion. Very cheap and tastes great. Best if eaten outside because the actual store is very small.