Carnegie Delicatessen & Restaurant serves New York, NY and is located in the 10019 ZIP code.
Reviews for Carnegie Delicatessen & Restaurant
Carnegie Delicatessen & Restaurant received an average rating of 3.81 out of 5 stars from 16 reviews.
Write a review
by Vitaly on 4/26/2021
by Artturi on 8/11/2021
by Artturi on 8/11/2021
by Gabriel on 1/31/2021
by Praise on 10/9/2021
by Praise on 10/9/2021
by gomez on 7/16/2021
by Heimirich on 5/28/2021
by Heimirich on 5/28/2021
by Amita on 1/14/2021
by Amita on 1/14/2021
by Abram on 3/14/2021
by Abram on 3/14/2021
by brockton on 6/29/2021
by EnD on 8/27/2021
by Farquhar on 2/16/2021
Carnegie Delis food is famous worldwide, and after your first bite of their expertly prepared food, youll understand why. In addition to unbeatable ... Read Full Editorial
My Review by DaveWallStNYC via Citysearch on 2/11/2016
I was so excited they were reopening from a year of darkness. I was so excited to run there for a Reuben some cheese cake. Two of us arrived tonight at 8:15 pm (after the theatre crowd left) and were shocked when they wouldn't let us in!…
My Review by jayc677830466 via Citysearch on 9/20/2012
Just had pastrami sandwich, and it was dry and luke warm. The quality and service really has gone down hill. Like many restaurants in Manhattan, it just became a tourist trap with mediocre food. I tried one down the block next day, and…
My Review by via Gayot on 8/10/2012
A Theater District landmark, the Carnegie has cramped tables, big crowds, wisecracking waiters, and high prices, but it's still one of the best places to get top-quality (and lean) corned beef and pastrami, enormous overstuffed sandwiches…
The Best Jewish Comfort Food Anywhere by LivRyan via Citysearch on 2/26/2012
I had seen Carnegie Deli in a lot of movies, so I always wanted to try it out. I grabbed my BFF Terry and she called a couple guys to take us there. OMG. The menu is so big that I couldn't even figure out what to have. After some…
GARGANTUAN May Not Be The Word...!!! by PhillipLisa via Citysearch on 11/4/2011
Carnegie Deli has always been our favorite deli so far of that genre (Katz
Great food by Tim1974 via Citysearch on 10/20/2011
A classic NYC landmark. Very crowded. Good cheesecake.
Good service! by Neil K. via Judy's Book on 4/9/2011
I just moved into a new apartment and went out to celebrate that night! When I got back home I realized I left my keys in the cab and got so angry. Luckily I had my phone with me and was able to find a locksmith to help me. They came right…
Great Experience by DrumMan via Citysearch on 4/3/2011
I love this place! The Woody Allen was awesome - Huge!! Only ate 1/4 of it but was phenomenal. The cheesecake made me cry it was sooo good!
I will be back for sure on my next trip to NYC!
Awful Experence by Donna3545 via Citysearch on 10/14/2010
Wow, what an awful experience. My friend and I visited Carnegie's, as recommended by a friend, to try their pie for breakfast. We wanted to split a pie for breakfast and the waitress refused to serve us. She couldn't believe we were…
Disappointing, possibly the worst meal that I have ever had by MacGunn via Citysearch on 10/4/2010
We travel to NYC on a regular basis and enjoy the off the beaten path restaurants and small neighborhood hole in the walls. Last night we decided do the opposite and give Carnegie deli a try....wow big mistake.... the matzah ball soup was…
Touristy Deli by Athena Chang via Citysearch on 6/21/2010
This is totally a tourist trap since because the quality of the sandwiches and the service here are just disappointing.
I don't like it. Plain and simple. They gave you A LOT OF MEAT for a $14 sandwich so compared to Katz, this is a…
Great Deli! by TheTripChick via Menuism on 2/21/2010
Extra star for the man behind the counter who was so charming that we ended up walking out with an extra...
Great Deli! by TheTripChick via Citysearch on 2/21/2010
Extra star for the man behind the counter who was so charming that we ended up walking out with an extra container of pickles AND a slice of cheesecake!\r
\r
We decided to grab something after seeing Billy Elliot and we didn't fee up to…
Great Experience by lisalynn1975 via Citysearch on 2/9/2010
This was our first experience with Carnegie Deli. Overall, I would recommend this deli. The place was crowded, but it is New York and it is good food. The sandwiches are pricey, but they are impressive. The sandwhiches are enormous…
Freshest Meat...Best Pastrami by KhaliKhai via Citysearch on 10/16/2009
Never saw so much meat in my plate. The pastrami looked and tasted great. Also the Hamburger and Egg Cream were excellent. Never had this type of experince form any Deli before. Little pricey.
Carnegie Deli : Serious Sandwiches by sugafree09 via Menuism on 10/5/2009
I'm never one to believe the hype, but Carnegie Deli is as good as if not better than what people have told...
Midtown temple of the high-piled Jewish deli sandwich. by Josh Ozersky via Citysearch on 9/17/2009
The Carnegie Deli is the Federal Reserve of delis: You can take it to the bank. This crowded, overpriced midtown spot is packed with tourists who come to gawk at the towering, high-piled corned beef and pastrami sandwiches. But they're…
Worst Deli in the entire city and midtown area! by chefvanessa via Citysearch on 8/2/2009
I am a concierge in midtown so I decided to go to Carnegie Deli to check why everybody wants to go there. It was a terrible experience I paid 18 for a corned beed sanwich- a specialty as per the menu- and there was basically no bread I…
Great cheesecake, terrible service by LadyBug via Citysearch on 5/4/2009
Although the desserts are good, they're not the best. A bit overpriced, so it doesn't make up for the terrible serivce. All of the servers, managers and hostesses are extremely rude!
a mainstay! by partaaaay via Citysearch on 3/25/2009
First place I go to eat whenever I'm in New York is the Carnegie Deli. Oh sure, there are lots of competition for the best deli in the City, but this place is a tradition for me!\r
\r
I've been comforted by their cold borscht pepto-bismol…
