New Bethel Ordinary

Reviews for New Bethel Ordinary

New Bethel Ordinary received an average rating of 5.00 out of 5 stars from 4 reviews.

by Ibragim on 5/31/2021

 

by Ibragim on 5/31/2021

 

by steve on 11/19/2020

 

by steve on 11/19/2020

 

Good Pizza and they serve Brains!! by Emily A via Insider Pages on 12/3/2007

The Ordinary has some of the best pizza around. You can order a large and I swear it weighs 15 pounds!!! This is also one of the only place's I know of that serves actual brains! I don't eat them, but I've heard people come from all…

A nice small town feel by Sara J via Insider Pages on 11/27/2007

I work in Beech Grove which is near wanamaker and I went here for lunch with some friends from work. I thought it had a nice small town feel to it. I ordered breaded cauliflower which was good, I love it and it's not a lot of places, the…

Great Pizza Even thouh I dont eat Pizza often by LaRue A via Insider Pages on 10/18/2007

This place is awsome and I actually am an African American that stay in the area . I am not a fan of pizza but this would be my overall choice Next to Chicagos Home Runn Inn Pizza. Its just a shame that they have not started delivering in…

Legendary Pizza by Trish P via Insider Pages on 7/5/2006

Locals know the legendary Ordinary pizza. So big you can hardly eat more than one piece. Stuffed full of grade A toppings it is a satisfying and filling meal. The only problem is they don't delivery. The ambiance is not much so you may…